Learning Contracts for Advanced Students

Dr. Jennifer Broome

In an era of heterogeneously grouped classrooms, teachers are responsible for meeting the academic needs of all students. What do you do, then, when an advanced student is finished with their work for the unit, has tested out of the unit, and/or knows the material better than you do? What happens when you’ve exhausted options like enrichment activities and sustained silent reading time? This is an excellent time to look at a learning contract.
What are learning contracts? Put simply, they are a tool for individualized instruction. They are a written agreement among the student, the teacher, and the student’s caregivers that allow the student to work on different content or at an advanced pace during class time. Learning contacts allow students to engage deeply with advanced content in your area or extend their knowledge of a specific topic that is a passion of the student. Some learning contract projects my students produced over the years include a paper on Victorian anti-semitism and the representation of Dracula as Jewish; how to create special effects makeup; programming a rudimentary software application to test students on The Great Gatsby; a short film about The Odyssey; a paper on the ethical dilemmas found in the Trolley Problem; and more. As you can see, the possibilities are basically limitless.
Learning contracts can be used as either a compacting tool or an enrichment tool. If the student learns at a more rapid pace than their peers, they are given individualized assignments to complete on their own during class time. (For information about how to compact curriculum, see the University of Connecticut's National Research Center on the Gifted and Talented webpage: https://nrcgt.uconn.edu/underachievement_study/curriculum-compacting/cc_8steps/). The second use case, enrichment, is for a student who has already demonstrated mastery of the unit’s knowledge and skills. Here, the instructor and the student negotiate a contract that spells out what the student will be doing during class time and a schedule for deliverables like a final paper or project. Note that learning contracts are not additional work! Learning contracts replace work; they do not add to work beneath the student’s level.
Once you’ve decided a learning contract is appropriate for your student, there is a process to follow to create a learning contract. First, the teacher, student, and caregivers meet. (If the caregivers cannot come to the school, the learning contract can be sent home for caregiver signatures of assent). This conference is held to agree that the student should and is willing to pursue a earning contract. The group must also decide if the student is going to go deeper into the content (depth of learning) or work on another concept or skill. This latter option is usually focused on an interest of the student. The interest can be a general topic in the discipline or an outside interest of the student.
The next item is to decide on a final product. This can be a research paper, a demonstration, a presentation to a school or government body, a piece of software, a choreographed performance, visual media like a short film, a produced and uploaded podcast episode— basically anything else you and the student can conceptualize as demonstrating the new knowledge or skill. At this point you also discuss what resources are needed for the student to successfully complete the project and determine how those resources will be acquired. Some projects may involve assistance from other teachers, whom the student should ask to help via a formal email. Some projects may involve the student purchasing materials, but for most projects all that is needed is time, a computer, and internet access.
Now that the final product is set, the teacher and student create a timeline for deliverables. Are pieces of the product going to be due along the way (recommended), or is the final project the only thing due? Now is a good time to also discuss grading. In higher grades, students should have input into how the product/their use of class time should be assessed. One good practice is to ask students to come up with a grading rubric themselves, and you can negotiate with the student about the rubric at a check-in meeting before the learning contract begins. On their own, the instructor adds aligned learning goals and curricular standards to the contract. Learning goals of a contract can be content based or skill based. Finally, the contract is signed and dated by the teachers, students, and caregivers.
Those seeking to implement learning contracts in the classroom for grades 3-8 should read Susan Winebrenner’s foundational text Teaching Gifted Kids in Today’s Classroom: Strategies and Techniques Every Teacher Can Use (4th edition). The book introduces learning contracts and provides sample contracts, along with many other strategies. Another resource for elementary and lower secondary teachers is Scott C. Greenwood’s On Equal Terms: How to Make the Most of Learning Contracts in Grades 4–9. Secondary teachers can view a sample contract for upper grades by clicking this link.
Learning contracts are an excellent resource for teachers who wish to differentiate instruction for advanced students. They can promote depth of learning, deep investigation into a topic, and student knowledge and skills. They can alleviate the boredom that often comes to advanced students when they are not being challenged, and allow for a multiplicity of ways to demonstrate knowledge. Learning contracts are a powerful tool in a teacher’s toolkit to challenge advanced learners, thus ensuring appropriate differentiation for all students.
Dr. Jennifer Broome is an Associate Professor of Education at Saint Mary’s College. Her teaching experience spans urban, rural, and suburban schools, community colleges, graduate programs, and undergraduate education, with a focus on pedagogy, curriculum, and educational philosophy. Her research interests include educational documents, curriculum and instruction, and the influence of philosophical frameworks, particularly the work of Michel Foucault, on education.





Comments